The novel follows Billie Nolan, a successful fertility specialist living in New York City. She grew up in a small town in Wisconsin and has built a demanding, carefully structured adult life far from home. At the beginning of the novel, Billie is engaged to Dean, a trauma surgeon from a wealthy Hamptons family. Their relationship appears solid, loving, and balanced. Dean is confident, supportive, and deeply committed to Billie. He proposes to her during a weekend at his family’s house in the Hamptons, and the proposal is elaborate and thoughtful, with both sets of parents present to celebrate. Billie feels chosen, safe, and certain that she is building the life she always wanted.
Soon after the engagement, Billie receives an unexpected voicemail from Mick O’Leary, her high school and college boyfriend. Mick was her first love and the person she once believed she would marry. They have not spoken in years. His message is brief and serious, asking her to call him back. The call unsettles her more than she expects, stirring memories she believed were long resolved. Dean notices her reaction and is wary but does not forbid contact.
The story then moves back in time to Billie’s adolescence in Wisconsin. As a teenager, she was studious, cautious, and ambitious, with dreams of becoming a doctor. Her closest friend was Erin, confident and outgoing, who encouraged Billie to take emotional risks. Billie fell deeply in love with Mick, a popular, kind football player with a complicated family life, including a younger sister, Maeve, who has Down syndrome. Billie and Mick built an intense emotional bond through friendship, long conversations, and shared vulnerability, but their relationship never aligned in timing. Mick dated other girls, most notably Kristy, while Billie stayed on the sidelines, heartbroken but loyal.
Continue Reading for Free
Register with your email address. We will send you a verification code before unlocking the article.
